Narrative Analysis of Ukraine Crisis; Contrasting Narratives and Counter-Narratives

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Professor, Department of International Relations, Faculty of Law and Political Sciences, Kharazmi University, Tehran, Iran

2 Postdoctoral Researcher in International Relations, Faculty of Law and Political Sciences, Kharazmi University, Tehran, Iran

10.22059/jcep.2023.361309.450152

Abstract

Introduction: Analyzing and interpreting a narrative can provide insight into the occurrence of an event, its causes, and its nature. Therefore, it can be said that narratives are a way to understand events. Narratives can be based on fact or fiction, but they help people make sense of the world through stories about themselves and others. This highlights the importance of narratives in shaping actions in the world. From this point of view, the current crisis in Ukraine can be seen as a story in which both Russia and Ukraine are trying to present their narratives of the history, causes, and methods of their conflict. The purpose of this research is to examine the narrative dimensions of this crisis from the point of the view of Putin and Zelensky, who are its main narrators. To achieve this, data will be collected and then analyzed from the statements of the leaders of Russia and Ukraine.
Research question: The question of the article based on the relationship between the narrative and the dynamics of contradiction is: what factor has made the crisis in Ukraine prolonged and inevitable?
Research hypothesis: hypothesis is that conflicting narratives as incompatible ideological and identity beliefs by the leaders of Russia and Ukraine is the inevitable ground of the conflict and has become one of the long-term crises.
Methodology and theoretical framework: The theoretical approach of the article is narrative analysis. The reason for choosing this theory is that narratives shape our understanding of ourselves and even create the physical world. The research method for this article is qualitative content analysis. In this method, the main concepts of the subject are extracted based on the selected theoretical approach. In the next step, these concepts are interpreted as research data by referring to the words and opinions of Putin and Zelensky as the ruling elite. This method is a good way to achieve the research goal because it seeks to understand the opinion and infer the specific characteristics of a crisis.
Results and Discussion: Certainly, the history of the Ukraine crisis dates back to the end of the Soviet Union in 1991. But the turning point and the beginning of the conflict of this crisis was in early 2014, after the annexation of Crimea to Russia. Although this annexation was the beginning of a military conflict, on the political side, the first friction was caused by Viktor Yanukovych decision against Ukraine's agreement with the European Union in 2013. Since then, political movements in favor of a nationalist approach to opposing Russian influence led to a period of protests against Yanukovych government and ultimately to his ouster from power in 2014. After this period, Ukraine's tendency towards the West increased the tension between this country and Russia. Therefore, in the post- Soviet period, while Ukraine was following policies to consolidate its independence, the Russian Federation sought to control Soviet geography, which was defined as the foreign country close to the Russian Federation. These foreign policy goals, carried out by the two countries, have caused security duality against each other and the emergence of some crises. In defining this security dilemma, the narrative of the elites of these two countries has always played a fundamental role. Narratives are often used by the ruling elite to incite society and resort to war and violence against others. In addition to the reconstructing the identities that make conflict possible, another key condition in the escalation of conflict, is the role of elites who mobilize identities and narratives for war. According to this role of leaders, Putin's narrative of preventive war, removal of threats and nationalism, delegitimization, negativity and victimization have formed the three elements of his narrative to legitimize and justify the attack on Ukraine, while Zelensky, on the other hand, in response to Putin's narrative, has presented an opposite narrative of inversion, marginalization, and contradiction and has declared his narrative fictional.
Conclusion: The narratives of Russia and Ukraine have been formed in such a way that these narratives do not allow for mutual understanding or a short-term solution to the crisis, and that only a tragedy or miracle can end the war. Consequently, as long as the conflicting narratives remain unchanged and less conflicting narratives replace them, even if the current crisis temporarily subsides, it is still waiting to happen again. The structure of both sides’ narratives shows that Putin's story is based on both material elements and normative-identity, but the dominant and provocative narrative is based on material and geopolitical elements. On the other hand, Ukrainian narratives have a normative and identity nature due to their connection with Western narratives and formation against Russian narratives.

Keywords

References

Al Jazeera (2022), “Russia-Ukraine Crisis: Zelenskyy’s Address in Full”, Al Jazeera Centre for Studies, Available at: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/ 2022/2/24/russia-ukraine-crisis-president-zelenskky-speech-in-full, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Baev, Pavel (2022), “Russia’s War in Ukraine Misleading Doctrine, Misguided Strategy”, Russie.Nei.Reports, No. 40, pp. 1-25, Available at: https://www.ifri.org/sites/default/files/atoms/files/baev_russia_war_ukraine_2022.pdf, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Bagheri, Reza and Alireza Kazami (2023), “The Re-Securitization of Russia by Nato and Western Countries Based on the Theory of Collective Security”, Journal of Country Studies, Vol. 1, No. 4, pp. 607-630, Available at: https://jcountst.ut.ac.ir/article_94136.html?lang=fa, (Accessed on: 23/09/2023),  [in Persian].
Bar-Tal, Daniel (2007), “Sociopsychological Foundations of Intractable Conflicts”, American Behavioral Scientist, Vol. 50, No. 11, pp. 1430-1453, (doi:10.1177/0002764207302462).
Brzezinski, Zbigniew (1997), The Grand Chessboard: American Primacy and Its Geostrategic Imperatives, Publisher: Basic Books.
Cenciarini, Luca (2020), “The Origins of the Ukrainian Crisis”, Research Gate, pp. 1-8, (doi:10.13140/RG.2.2.36305.97120).
D'Anieri, Paul (2023), Ukraine and Russia: From Civilized Divorce to Uncivil War, United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press.
Demir, Sertif (2022), “The 2022 Russia-Ukraine War: Reasons and Impacts”, Mehmet Seyfettin Erol, Vol. 6, No. 1, pp. 13-40, Available at: https://dergipark.org.tr/en/download/article-file/2369182, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Euronews (2023), “Ukraine War: Zelenskyy and Putin Both Promise Victory in New Year Speeches”, Available at: https://www.euronews.com/2023/01/01/ukraine-war-zelenskyy-and-putin-both-promise-victory-in-new-year-speeches, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Farwell, James (2022), “How Zelensky Seized Control over the Narrative in Ukraine”, The Defense Post, Available at:  https://www.thedefensepost.com/ 2022/08/11/zelensky-narrative-ukraine/, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Federman, Sarah (2016), “Narrative Approaches to Understanding and Responding to Conflict”, International Journal of Conflict Engagement and Resolution, Vol. 4, No. 2, pp. 154-171, (doi:10.5553/IJCER/221199652016004002002)
Franz, Benedikt (2022), “Narrative Time and International Relations”, Journal of International Relations and Development, Vol. 25, pp. 761–783, Available at: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1057/s41268-022-00261-3, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Ghaempanah, Babak and Svetlana N. Khapova (2020), “Identity Play and the Stories We Live by”, Journal of Organizational Change Management, Vol. 33, No. 5, pp. 683-695, Available at: https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/ 10.1108/JOCM-07-2019-0238/full/html, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Hagström, Linus and Karl Gustafsson (2019), “Narrative Power: How Storytelling Shapes East Asian International Politics”, Cambridge Review of International Affairs, Vol. 32, No. 4, pp. 387-406, (doi:10.1080/09557571.2019.1623498).
He, Gang (2022), “The Narrative Turn in the Study of International Relations”, Academic Journal of Humanities & Social Science, Vol. 5, No. 6, pp. 77-8, Available at: https://www.francis-press.com/uploads/papers/KwLDr694DEtWgr BZkzhNbtUmTiuJfwdVwGV160PC.pdf, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Hopkins, Valerie (2022), “Highlights from Putin’s Address on Breakaway Regions in Ukraine”, The New York Times, Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/ 2022/02/21/world/europe/putin-speech-transcript.html, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Howarth, David (1998), “Discourse Theory”, Translated Seyed Ali Asghar Soltani, Political Science Quarterly, Vol. 1, No. 2, pp. 156-183, Available at: http://psq.bou.ac.ir/article_7455.html, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023), [in Persian].
Huseynov, Vasif (2017), “Revisiting the Ukraine Crisis: Realist Reflections on Causes and Consequences”, Centre for European Studies, Vol. 9, No. 4, pp. 582-596, Available at: https://www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/198527/1/ ceswp-v09-i4-p582-596.pdf, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Iman, Mohammad Taqi and Mahmoud Reza Noushadi (2011), “Qualitative Content Analysis”, Pazhuhesh, Vol. 3. No. 2, pp. 15-44, Available at: http://pajohesh.nashriyat.ir/node/62, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023), [in Persian].
Kalantari, Fathollah and Hassan Mohammadi Monfared (2023), “The Results of the War Between Russia and Ukraine in the Formation of the New World Order”, Journal of Strategic Defense Studies, Vol. 21, No. 92, pp. 178-210, Available at: https://sds.sndu.ac.ir/article_2373.html, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023), [in Persian].
Koolaee, Elaheh and Mohammad Sedaghat (2017), “Ukraine Crisis and the Russian Military Doctrine”, Central Eurasia Studies, Vol. 10, No. 1, pp. 205-220, Available at: https://jcep.ut.ac.ir/article_62908.html, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023), [in Persian].
Kuusisto, Riikka (2019), International Relations Narratives: Plotting World Politics (New International Relations), New York: Routledge.
Lee, Seow Ting (2022), “A Battle for Foreign Perceptions: Ukraine’s Country Image in the 2022”, Place Branding and Public Diplomacy, pp. 1-14, (doi:10.1057/s41254-022-00284-0).
Mankoff, Jeffrey (2022), “Russia’s War in Ukraine: Identity, History, and Conflict”, Center for Strategic & International Studies, pp. 1-12, Available at: https://www.csis.org/analysis/russias-war-ukraine-identity-history-and-conflict, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Masters, Jonathan (2022), “Ukraine: Conflict at the Crossroads of Europe and Russia”, Council on Foreign Relations, Available at: https://www.cfr.org/ backgrounder/ukraine-conflict-crossroads-europe-and-russia, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Mateo, Emma (2018), “The Ukraine Crisis: A Clash of Narratives?” The University Consortium Conference, Available at:  https://uc.web.ox.ac.uk/article/the-ukraine-crisis-a-clash-of-narratives, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
McFaul, Michael (2014), “Faulty Powers: Who Started the Ukraine Crisis?”, Foreign Affairs, Vol. 93, No. 6, pp. 167-178, Available at: https://we.hse.ru/ data/2018/01/21/1163351880/Faulty_powers.pdf, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
McGlynn, Jade (2023), “Why Russia Markets Itself as an Anti-Colonial Power to Africans”, Foreign Policy, Available at: https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/ 02/08/russia-ukraine-colonialism-diplomacy-africa/ (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Mearsheimer, John J.  (2022), “The Causes and Consequences of the Ukraine War”, Horizons: Journal of International Relations and Sustainable Development, No. 21, pp. 12-27, Available at: https://www.cirsd.org/files/000/000/009/75/ 401141581c665840ebdf7c1304da4a9486211f99.pdf, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Metsola, Roberta (2023), “President Zelenskyy Says Russia is a Grave Threat to the European Way of Life”, News European Parliament, Available at: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press-room/20230208IPR72901/ president-zelenskyy-says-russia-is-a-grave-threat-to-the-european-way-of-life, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Mirinamniha, Milad and Ali Omidi (2022), “Cultural Identity and Conflict Between Russia and Ukraine”, Central Asia and the Caucasus Journal, Vol. 28, No. 119, pp. 125-152, Available at: http://ca.ipisjournals.ir/article_700772.html, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023), [in Persian].
Miskimmon, Alister, Ben O’Loughlin and Laura Roselle (2018), “Strategic Narrative: 21st Century Diplomatic Statecraft”, Revista Mexicana de Política Exterior, Vol. 113, pp. 1-19, Available at: https://www.pureadmin.qub.ac.uk/ ws/portalfiles/portal/156934902/Miskimmon_OLoughlin_Roselle_Strategic_Narrative_21st_Century_Statecraft_2018.pdf, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Moshirzadeh, Homeira (2023), “Traumatic Narratives Emotions and Foreign Policy: Theoretical Hypotheses on The Basis of Iranian Experiences Subject Areas: Research in Theoritical Politics”, Pizhūhish-i siyāsat-i nazāri, Vol. 17, No. 32, pp. 77-106, Available at: https://political.ihss.ac.ir/fa/Article/40807, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023). [in Persian].
Mousaei Ali and Enayatollah Yazdani (2021), “The Role of Incorporeal Factors in the Annexation of the Crimea Peninsula to the Russian Federation”, Political and International Approaches, Vol. 12, No. 66, pp. 153-180, Available at: https://piaj.sbu.ac.ir/article_101503.html, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023), [in Persian].
Myshlovska, Oksana (2022/A), “Conflict Dynamics as a Narrative Process”, Central European Journal of International and Security Studies, Vol. 16, No. 3, pp. 76-107, (doi: 10.51870/GDIM2629).
Myshlovska, Oksana (2022/B), “Understanding the Roots of the Russia-Ukraine War and the Misuse of History”, the Geneva Graduate Institute, Available at: https://www.graduateinstitute.ch/communications/news/understanding-roots-russia-ukraine-war-and-misuse-history, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Nouri, Alireza (2009), “The Developments of Anti-US Positions in the Russian Foreign Policy; the Putin's Foreign Policy”, Strategic Studies Quarterly, Vol. 11, No. 42, pp. 853-876, Available at: https://www.quarterly.risstudies.org/ article_1076.html, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023), [in Persian].
Putin, Vladimir (2022/A), “on the Historical Unity of Russians and Ukrainians”, Legal Tools, Available at: https://www.legal-tools.org/doc/tt382m/pdf, pp. 1-18, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Putin, Vladimir (2022/B), “Full Text: Putin’s Declaration of War on Ukraine”, The Spectator, Available at: https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/full-text-putin-s-declaration-of-war-on-ukraine/, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Putin, Vladimir (2023), “Presidential Address to Federal Assembly”, Official Internet Resources of the President of Russia, Available at:  http://www.en.kremlin.ru/events/president/transcripts/70565, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Roberts, Geoffrey (2022), “Now or Never: The Immediate Origins of Putin’s Preventative War on Ukraine”, Journal of Military and Strategic Studies, Vol. 22, No. 2, pp. 4-27, Available at: https://quarterly.risstudies.org/article_ 1076.htmlhttps://jmss.org/article/view/76584/56335, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Rubio, Ángel (2022), Zelensky’s Discourse During the Russian Invasion of Ukraine: How the War of Narratives Influences Conflicts, Final Dissertation, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences: Universidad Pontificia Comillas.
Sarıkaya, Burak (2017), “Evaluation of The Ukrainian Crisis Within the Context of Regional Security Complex Theory”, Afro Eurasian Studies Journal, Vol. 6, No. 1&2, pp. 33-53, Available at: https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/download/article-file/700186, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Shokoohi, Saeed (2023), “Putin's Misperceptions and the Russian Invasion of Ukraine in 2022”, Central Eurasia Studies, Vol. 15, No. 2, pp. 265-288, Available at: https://jcep.ut.ac.ir/article_90941.html, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023), [in Persian].
Suny, Ronald (2022), “The Ukraine Conflict is a War of Narratives”, The Conversation, Available at: https://theconversation.com/the-ukraine-conflict-is-a-war-of-narratives-and-putins-is-crumbling-192811, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Titherington, Katie (2022), “A Psychological Perspective on Putin’s War with Ukraine”, E-International Relations, pp. 1-3, (doi: e-ir.info/pdf/99874).
Wax, Eddy and Other (2023), “Zelenskyy Seeks to Place Ukraine at Home in the EU”, Politico, Available at: https://www.politico.eu/article/volodymyr-zelenskyy-ukraine-home-eu/, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Wilson, Andrew (2023), “Ukraine at War: Baseline Identity and Social Construction”, Nationsand Nationalism, pp. 1–10, (doi: org/10.1111/nana. 12986).
Zakharchenko, Artem (2022), “The Clash of Strategic Narratives in the Russo-Ukrainian War”, Forum for Ukrainian Studies, Available at: https://ukrainian-studies.ca/2022/09/18/the-clash-of-strategic-narratives-in-the-russo-ukrainian-war/, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Zaniewicz, Maciej (2020), “Ukraine’s Foreign Policy in President Zelensky’s First Year”, PISM Bulletin, No. 130, pp. 1-2, Available at: https://www.pism.pl/ publications/Ukraines_Foreign_Policy_in_President_Zelenskys_First_Year, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Zelensky, Volodymyr (2022), “Top 55 Volodymyr Zelensky Quotes”, Gracious Quotes, Available at: https://graciousquotes.com/volodymyr-zelensky/, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Zelensky, Volodymyr (2023/A), “Speech by Volodymyr Zelensky to Representatives of the Public, Political and Expert Circles of the Kingdom of the Netherlands and International Institutions Based in the Hague”, President of Ukraine Official Website, Available at: https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/ vistup-volodimira-zelenskogo-pered-predstavnikami-gromadskos-82653, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Zelensky, Volodymyr (2023/B), “Address by President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelensky February, The Year of Invincibility”, President of Ukraine Official Website, Available at: https://www.president.gov.ua/en/news/zvernennya-prezidenta-ukrayini-volodimira-zelenskogo-lyutij-81213, (Accessed on: 23/05/2023).
Central Eurasia Studies
Volume 16, Issue 2
Autumn & Winter
March 2024
Pages 247-272

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics